Home Title Lock Scam?

Those ads are designed to be alarming, but they often exaggerate both the risk and the effectiveness of the product.

Based on my research, while “home title lock” services are legitimate monitoring companies, consumer protection experts and agencies like the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) warn that their services are often unnecessary and their marketing is misleading.

Here’s a breakdown of the facts versus the claims.

1. What “Home Title Lock” Actually Is (and Isn’t)

The name “home title lock” is the most misleading part. These services do not and cannot “lock” your title in the way you can lock your credit report.

• What it IS: A paid subscription monitoring service. It scans public property records and alerts you after a document (like a new deed or lien) has been filed in your name.
• What it is NOT: It is not a preventative measure. It does not stop a fraudulent document from being filed. It is also not title insurance, which is a separate product that can help cover your legal costs if a title dispute arises.

2. How Common is Home Title Theft?

The TV ads make it sound like an epidemic. In reality, this specific crime—where a scammer forges a deed to “steal” your home—is very rare.

While real estate fraud is a real problem, it more often targets vacant properties, vacation homes, or properties where the owner is deceased. For a typical homeowner living in their house, the risk is extremely low.

3. You Don’t Legally Lose Your Home to a Forged Deed

This is the most important fact: A forged deed is a fraudulent, void document. It has no legal power.

If a scammer forges your name and files a fake deed, they have not legally taken ownership of your home. You are still the rightful owner. However, it can be a significant and expensive legal hassle to prove the fraud and get the public record corrected.

4. How to Protect Yourself for Free

The good news is you don’t need to pay a monthly fee for the same (or better) protection.

• Check for Free County Alerts: This is the #1 alternative. Many U.S. counties (often through the County Recorder, Clerk, or Assessor’s office) offer a free property alert service. You can sign up, and they will automatically email you whenever a document is filed on your property. This provides the exact same service as “home title lock,” but at no cost.
• Watch Your Mail: Pay attention to your key bills. If your property tax bill, water bill, or mortgage statement suddenly stops arriving, that is a major red flag. It could mean a scammer has changed the mailing address on your records.
• Check Your Owner’s Title Insurance: When you bought your home, you almost certainly purchased an owner’s title insurance policy. Review this policy. An “enhanced” policy often includes coverage for post-policy fraud, meaning the insurance company may pay the legal fees to help you fight a fraudulent claim and restore your title.

---

⚖️ The Verdict: Is It a Scam?

• As a service: It’s a “legitimate” monitoring service, but one with limited value.
• As a marketing concept: It’s often called a “ploy” by consumer advocates because it sells a solution to an uncommon problem by using fear-based advertising, all while a free alternative exists.

For most homeowners, these services are an unnecessary expense. You are better off signing up for your county’s free property alerts and ensuring you know where your owner’s title insurance policy is.